Saturday, September 24, 2022

STRENGTHEN YOUR SUBMISSIONS STRATEGY, PART 1 by Adele Gardner (writing mysteries as Max Jason Peterson)

No matter how you steel yourself, rejection after rejection takes a toll. It’s easy to lose confidence and feel your work isn’t good enough—when what’s really needed is to keep trying until you reach that one editor (or agent) who loves your work. Rather than feeling rejected, take heart by using statistics to bolster your stamina. As the author of over 475 published short stories, poems, art, & articles, and as literary executor for my father, I’ll share the system that inspires me to keep submitting, even to the tough markets—and helps me think about new strategies to build on strengths that might otherwise go unnoticed.

After I returned from the Clarion West Writers Workshop, I would occasionally hear my fellow writers encourage one another by sharing a tale of how many submissions it took to sell a piece. I started keeping count of the number of times things went out before they sold, hoping to encourage myself to keep going. But it was very unscientific. One problem was how quickly I'd give up on the pro tier when feeling discouraged. I wanted to follow Roger Zelazny's rubric, making a list of the highest- to lowest-paying markets, then sending a story down the list until it sold or got shelved. But in addition to making exceptions for unexpected projects with exciting themes, I too often found I'd doubt myself and my story's worth after a few tries, then give up on potential pro sales.

However, several of my stories sold to pro markets after having exhausted all potential matches at semipro and token pay tiers. This was a revelation to me, clearly indicating it wasn't that my writing lacked quality—it had simply not yet found that one editor who loved it. 

I started thinking about ways to improve my submission strategies. I added a count of acceptances, and each time one came in, I updated the average number of submissions needed to get there, per type of work (fiction, poetry). Instead of counting up how many submissions an individual piece had endured, I now had an average that seemed to stay fairly consistent. This was so encouraging I found myself attaching less importance and disappointment to individual rejections, instead seeing them as a chance to send the work back out and move closer to that magic number. 

Most recently, I've been compiling individual statistics by the year. I get a better picture of where I'm doing well, so I can capitalize on my strengths. I can also see potential problem areas where I might want to improve. Best of all, I can see the average number of submissions needed for a sale is steadily diminishing. 

I'm hoping that something about my quest might help inspire a eureka moment about your own work methods. Though your process may end up much different, just in case it is a useful starting point, I'll outline how I gather statistics while tracking submissions. Please don't be daunted by the level of detail I keep. You can keep as little or as much as you want, using any type of file you like.

I started with a word processing file using tables (which I’ll describe at the end for those who prefer it), then moved to a spreadsheet structure, which I love for its ability to sort, count, and find data.

Some of the useful features of my spreadsheet include:

  • Sorting by length of poem or story, or by type of poem (formal or free verse)
  • Sorting by market, to see what's already gone out, whether something's there currently, typical length of time to respond
  • Where to send the material next, with suggestions grouped by pay tier
  • Sorting by whether the material is currently out or previously published
  • Sorting by when things were submitted, with the newest first, so I can count submissions by time period

In the next article, I'll describe the setup of my own files by way of example, but you should experiment and find what works best for you. Good luck, and keep on plugging away at those submissions!


For more information about Adele Gardner (writing mysteries as Max Jason Peterson), visit their website: www.gardnercastle.comHalloween Hearts: Poems by Adele Gardner is available through Jackanapes Press.


Michael Rigg said...

Absolutely excellent! Very informative and helpful. I'm waiting the next installment(s). You should think of turning this into a lecture for the HRW Traveling Pen Series.

Teresa Inge said...

Outstanding information. Especially if someone submits to multiple markets frequently. Thank you!

Kim Thorn said...

Thanks Adele! Wonderful blog post and great information. I’m looking forward to the next installment. I love this idea and was wondering if you will show us an example of your spreadsheet. Sorry I’m more of a dual learner!

Kim Thorn said...

Not sure where dual came from. I am a visual learner. Lol!

Maria Hudgins said...

Great information, Adele! Thank you!

Max Jason Peterson said...

Thanks so much, Mike! I appreciate your feedback & encouragement so much.

Max Jason Peterson said...

Thanks so much, Kim! That is a great idea. I'll find a way to include screenshots as well as describing it.

The history of Sweet Tea by Teresa Inge

      As summer heats up, Americans  will be looking to cool down, and what better way than with a cold glass of refreshing sweet, iced tea....